A Ugandan court has sentenced a nurse to three years in prison for negligence over the potential infection of a two-year-old boy with HIV.
Rosemary Namubiru, who is HIV-positive, was criminally negligent by using an intravenous needle, that she had accidentally pricked her finger with, on the child, the court ruled.
The child was not infected and HIV/Aids activists condemned the trial.
The case was keenly watched and some papers dubbed her the "killer nurse".
The boy's father, Daniel Mushabe, welcomed the ruling, saying he hoped the case would spur President Yoweri Museveni to sign into law a bill which criminalises the transmission of HIV.
The bill - already approved by parliament - says anyone who wilfully passes on HIV could face a fine of $1,900 (£1,130), a 10-year jail term or both.
Namubiru's five-month trial has been closely followed in Uganda, reports the BBC's Patience Atuhaire from the capital, Kampala.
Many members of the public were condemned the nurse, while HIV/Aids activists defended the 64-year-old, our reporter says.
Handing down sentence in a packed court room, chief magistrate Olive Kazaarwe said Namubiru lacked remorse for her actions.
Namubiru, a paediatric nurse with 30 years' experience, had maintained her innocence during the trial, and the boy was not infected with the virus.
Her lawyer David Kabanda said he was unhappy with the ruling, and was considering what to do next.
Namubiru said she had decided to administer intra-venous fluids through the boy's arm, but had difficulty finding a vein in which she could insert the needle.
It was then that she accidentally hurt her finger, but had no intention of passing the virus to the boy, she said.
Welcoming the ruling, Mr Mushabe said he hoped doctors and nurses will now "think twice" in future when treating patients.
"It is extremely hard to feel happiness in such circumstances without really getting to the bottom of the matter and finding out why Namubiru, without any provocation, went out of her way to infect our child," he said.
HIV/Aids activists said the nurse had not acted maliciously, and her life had been ruined.
The public anger towards her show the stigma people with HIV/Aids still face, they said.
Uganda won worldwide praise for its vigorous campaign against HIV/Aids, which helped reduce the prevalence of the virus - which reached 30% of the population in the 1990s - to single-digit figures.
However, the rate has started to rise again in recent years...culled
*why is someone with HIV a nurse and handling a needle?I feel so sorry for her but i dont think she had malicious intent.awwwwww.
I don't think it was a malicious intent either but oh boy! That was too risky!!!
ReplyDeleteAfter pricking herself accidentally ,did she go ahead to use the same needle??
This is really scary,the world is not safe!
Stella medical professionals with HIV are allowed to practice but not allowed to carry out invasive procedures like what she was doing.
DeleteYeah, I don't think she had malicious intent but how can someone with HIV be handling needles and injecting people?
DeleteEveryone has a past and so do you.....click my name to read more
Feel sorry for her, too.
ReplyDeleteStella jst hear urself talk. What do u mean why is someone with hiv a nurse and handling a needle? E be like say dem don nack u better prick for nyt nd u never regain ur senses.
ReplyDeleteTheir names though....
Haney
u are stupid for saying that to Stella. y wuld an Aids nurse be in such section? she was supposed to be at a place where she will not av direct contact with patients. Africa is still backwards anyway.
DeleteDearest anon, d last time i checked i was referring to Stella nd i m entitled to my opinion. Pls channel ur frustration elsewhere biko. Why is an hiv patient a nurse? Even my illitrate grand mother can never reasob dat way.
DeleteHaney
You're the one who is backward anon 9.16. That's why there's so much discrimination and stigmatization of HIV carriers in Africa. So they should put her in a different section because she has HIV? You're an idiot.
DeleteAs for this nurse, her action is criminal and her sentence is well deserved. Even if she didnt have HIV, why should a nurse prick herself first and then go on to use the same needle on a patient? Moreso when she knew she had an infectious virus. Because he's a two year old boy and he couldn't protest? Evil. Criminal.
Y did need 2 insult Haney? She neva insulted Stella lat tym I checked nacking better prick n gud thing.
Deleteanonymous 11:40 im sure u are sick. that is not discrimination but preventive measure. take a look at this avoidable mistake, now u will tell d little boy sorry for getting infected? when it was supposed to be avoided? did I said she shuld be discriminated? ok go n get urself infected out of pity thats if u are not already.
DeleteThis isn't discrimination. She has d virus n shouldn't b in a department where she will b handling needles, pins razor etc. That is not 2 say she can't work. She can b in pharmacy, reception, can b taking vital signs n many more. Btw, she accidentally pricked herself n didn't care 2 change d pin? Isn't dat carelessness on her path? @ pinkshell wat is she suing 4? Who is she suing? HiV/AIDS is still a deadly disease n d need 2 b careful wit sharp objects around its carrier cannot b over emphasised.
DeleteAnd y put her picture on the net?
ReplyDelete1st dey av ruined her chances of eva getting a job and living a normal life.
She shld sue!
Did you read well? She's going thru trial and you think there are no journalists in the court room and even networks interviewing her and her lawyers? What is she suing for? Someone who might spend the next 4yrs in prison?
DeleteQutie!
DeleteIs dia a prob?
Y do u always take wateva i say personally(i can almost ear u shout)?
U shld calm ur tits!
I meant after her trial she shld sue, d display of pics is so unnecessary.
Do u no the numba of criminals/rapist n co whose pics do nt surface online?
Plz Watevea ur ish are plz try JESUS except its ur child dat wz almost infected!
Stella is right! Am nt saying patient wit HIV should nt be given work bt nt dat kind of risky 1. Haba dat ws close. Thank God 4 everything n please sending her 2 prison is nt d best thing.
ReplyDeleteMrs Davido
Hmm... Speechless!
ReplyDeleteZuma missing diamondblinqZ
Stella with ur last statement u sound like an. Illiterate
ReplyDeleteLmao! My tots exactly. U neva know dat ur highly reverred doctor is carrying d virus. Mtcheeeeew
DeleteHaney
I just had that same thought
DeleteAhahaha,easy with ur words abeg.
DeleteI feel so srry 4 her.
Guess u are an infected idiot to say that. HIV infected people are not supposed to work in such areas becos there is 90% possibility of infecting people u fool.
DeleteUk allows HIV infected nurses n doctors to operate.
ReplyDelete#them say na human rights
I pray the cure is found already
It's taken so long
Jst speechless shaa, I pray d cure is found quick, who r we 2judge, No matter how careful we are, its stil Gods doin at d end of the day.
ReplyDeleteShe should stop being a nurse pls!cos very soon frustration can make her intentions become malicious!
ReplyDeleteWhat if she got HIV through her hospital work? There are little measures in place to protect health care workers
ReplyDeleteYes it is taken so long to find a cure. Most of all this men have hiv why can't they channel their money to finding a lasting cure. Anyways Hiv is no longer a death sentence but a life sentence. Soorry pooor niurse.
ReplyDeleteSdk readers let me ask this if you found out that the lady or guy you want to get married to is Hiv positive and truly you love this person and find happiness in him or her. With the current treatment of Hiv will you stick with the person or Run for ur life.
ReplyDeleteWhy is it that if Stella put news story about Hiv I noticed that the comments are always poor. It seems most of you here are Hiv positive. But if its sex matters comments go reach 1 thousand. Lol
ReplyDeleteShe looks evil. She probably did it intentionally. Which kind mistake be that. EVIL NURSE. Three years is too small for her.
ReplyDeletestella you are just so ignorant its amazing.....fools will just follow u and be asking stupid questions....they can work so far they wear gloves to perform this kind of function..all medical personnel are supposed to wear it too....i wonder if the parents would have made any noise if it was their son who was HIV positive..they cannot be discriminated upon cos of the disease....stupid mamie, except fluid is exchanged you do not contact HIV so why cant they operate if they have the right protective gear?
ReplyDeleteanonymous 9.16 am youareso ignorant backward and a bloody liar....in developed countries they have direct contact with patients but adequately wearing the right protection...in this case when she accidentaly hurt her finger she should have discontinued the procedure.....howbeit the case, it doesn't show any evidence there was any premeditated intention to infect the boy......
ReplyDeletewhat are u talking abt? im a registered nurse n I live in Italy. We go for medical check up every 6 months by law. when someone is found with d virus he or she is given 2 options, either she agrees that his/her colleagues are told abt her medical condition or she quits. if she acceptes she will be placed where she will not be allowed d use of sharp objects becos of mistakes like this. will someone come to d hospital to get cured n end up leaving with a sickness that has no cure?
DeleteTo be honest,hiv/aids victims aren't suppose to work where they can easily.infect people.. You can never be too careful
ReplyDeleteHhhmmmm....there is actually nothing wrong with that if you ask me. I think she got punished for been wreckless. She should have disposed the niddle after it pierced her finger. 'I don't care attitude', not good for a nurse.
ReplyDeleteGBN.
Paragon7ven.
Hhhmmmm....there is actually nothing wrong with that if you ask me. I think she got punished for been wreckless. She should have disposed the niddle after it pierced her finger. 'I don't care attitude', not good for a nurse.
ReplyDeleteGBN.
Paragon7ven.
Sending her to jail is too much in my opinion, the most they could have done is revoke her licence to practice nursing and fine her, And it says the boy is not infected (which means he was given post exposure prophylaxis), so that was a rather harsh punishment.
ReplyDeleteIn Nigeria, they will say she is not guilty, and ask her to pay a fine of 100k... We have a long way to go in this country.
ReplyDeleteSalt
Am a nurse in one of d teaching hospitals in Nigeria.i keep saying it everyday.Doctors and nurses she be screened for HIV every 3 months.Anybody dat test positive will be transferred 2 a department where he wnt be in direct contact wit patients. I see things everyday.Health workers infect patients deliberately or non deliberately everyday in d hosp. If u go 2 hosp plsss be careful now. Make sure whatever dey r giving 2 u is done in ur prescence. Cases in theatres is story 4 another day.Negligence on d increase.Chizzy
ReplyDeleteThey can work as long as they wear gloves.
ReplyDeleteAm pregnant o I went for immunisation don't knw d name for it sha when I got there d nurse just brought out a needle with d drug already in it from a carton I was surprise cos usually d always open d needle infront of me i asked d nurse to use a new needle she said she just opened it I told her that I didn't see when she opened it she got angry n started talking I just stood up n ask another nurse to come n giv me d injection d new nurse told me not to be angry she then brought out a new needle gave me d injection n I left. . Naso d nurse for giv me unknown disease o. Pls wen u go for injection make sure u see when d needle is being opened.
ReplyDeleteAs a health worker, I have seen patients infect health workers too..yeah! Sometimes u help a patient with someting and he or she had a needle in the bag and you get pricked by it...it happens here in Nigeria and the health workers live with it........Hiv is not written on the face..that doctor u run to at the slightest instance may have it, the nurse that cares for u may have it.......safety measures should be taken to avoid transmission.....in a lot of countries, heakth workers with HIV work with non infected patients....Nigeria is no exemption
ReplyDelete